Representation of the gbahali based upon
eyewitness descriptions (© Tim Morris)
Since
1900, the West African country of Liberia, still plentifully supplied with
coastal mangrove swamps and interior rainforests, and long deemed a
biodiversity hotspot by zoologists, has been the scene of at least four major
zoological discoveries of species new to science or rediscoveries of species
believed extinct. Namely, the giant forest hog Hylochoerus meinertzhageni, the pygmy hippopotamus Choeropsis liberiensis, Jentink's duiker
Cephalophus jentinki, and the
Liberian mongoose Liberiictis kuhni.
All of
these are mammals, of course, but there is also some thought-provoking evidence
to suggest that a fifth major zoological find is still waiting to be made here
– and this time of the reptilian variety.
West Africa's dwarf crocodile, note its short
snout (public domain)
Four
species of crocodilian are known to exist in Liberia. These are the Nile
crocodile Crocodylus niloticus, the
West African dwarf crocodile Osteolaemus tetraspis,
the West African slender-snouted crocodile Mecistops
cataphractus, and the West African or sacred crocodile C. suchus (only quite recently delineated from the Nile crocodile
as a valid distinct species in its own right). The first two are restricted to
this country's coastal swamps, and are considered rare, as is the third (a
little-studied, human-avoiding species), whereas the fourth one, which occurs
further inland, is quite common.
However,
native Liberians also speak of a fifth crocodile-like creature, currently
unknown to science, which they refer to as the gbahali (pronounced 'bar-hye'),
and consider to be larger and more dangerous than even the Nile crocodile –
itself a highly aggressive, notorious man-eater that can grow up to 21 ft long.
The
gbahali first attracted widespread Western attention on 20 December 2007, when
veteran American cryptozoologist Loren Coleman published on the mystery beast
website Cryptomundo a communication
that he had received the previous day. It was from a correspondent named
John-Mark Sheppard (some accounts spell his surname as Shephard) – an American
missionary working at that time with an international relief and development
organisation in northernmost Liberia's Lofa County, near this country's border
with Guinea.
In his
communication, Sheppard revealed that he had learnt from the indigenous people
there about several strange, unidentified creatures that may be of potential
cryptozoological interest, including the gbahali. He had spoken to a number of
alleged eyewitnesses who claimed to have seen the latter mystery beast in
recent years, and according to their testimony, as documented by Sheppard:
It is described as being like a crocodile or monitor
lizard, but much larger (up to 25 or 30 ft long). It has an armored back with
three rows of serrations running down it, a powerful tail, and a short snout
with many large teeth. It is known to be an ambush predator, carrying its prey
underwater to drown before coming on shore to eat it.
Sheppard
even travelled to a village deep in the Liberian rainforest where the fishermen
claimed to have actually caught gbahali specimens, using nets to capture them
and shotguns to kill them, before butchering their carcases for meat, which
they then sold at local markets. They had even preserved the skull of one such
specimen, which had been retained in the village until rebels invaded it during
this country's civil war (which ended in 2003) and set it ablaze, destroying
everything there, including that scientifically-precious gbahali skull.
When
interviewing the villagers, Sheppard showed them various illustrations of
modern-day and prehistoric crocodilians and crocodilian-like animals that he
had downloaded from the internet. Of these, the creature that they considered
most similar in appearance to the gbahali was an artistic reconstruction of the
likely appearance in life of a prehistoric reptile from North America's Late Triassic
Period, known as Postosuchus. This
very sizeable beast, up to 6 m long, belonged to a long-extinct taxonomic
family whose members, known as rauisuchians, were related to crocodilians.
Representation of the possible appearance in life
of Postosuchus in quadrupedal mode (©
Nobu Tamura/Wikipedia – CC BY-SA 3.0 licence)
The
locals stated that the head and body of Postosuchus
as depicted in the artistic reconstruction resembled that of the gbahali,
but that its legs were more erect (i.e. supporting its body from below) than
the gbahali's, which are allegedly semi-erect in stance (i.e. more sprawling),
like those of crocodilians.
Continuing
his narrative, Sheppard stated:
The river in which these creatures are said to live
is very remote, passing through large areas of uninhabited forest. They are said
to mainly be seen during the rainy season, when they travel upstream to look
for food. They are greatly feared by the local population, because they have
been known to kill people.
Indeed,
according to Sheppard one such incident may have occurred as recently as
November 2007, just a month before he had sent his communication to Coleman. A
man had been attacked and killed by a possible gbahali near a village named
Gelema, on that selfsame river. When the United Nations police were sent there
to investigate this incident, all that they could find was the victim's head
and a few body parts that the creature had left behind on the river bank. This
ties in with local claims mentioned above by Sheppard whereby the gbahali
drowns its victim, then comes ashore with their dead body to consume it there.
Worthy
of note, incidentally, is that back when Gelema's official town meeting house
was built, its length was deliberately constructed so as to correspond with
that of a gbahali that had been killed there some years previously.
Consequently, this grim mystery beast would indeed appear to be native to the
area encompassing Gelema.
Also
of interest, as specifically pointed out by Sheppard when concluding his
account of the gbahali, the local people do not consider this beast to be in
any way magical or supernatural. Instead, they simply look upon it as just
another normal, ordinary animal native to their locality (albeit a very large,
dangerous one), nothing more – which in turn tends to lend plausibility to
their testimony concerning it.
Sheppard
ended with a tantalizingly brief mention of a photograph that had supposedly
been taken of a gbahali sometime in the previous 10 years during an attempt to
capture this creature, but he made no mention of what had happened to it,
always assuming of course that such a picture had indeed been obtained.
After
spending many years behind the camera as a first-rate, highly-acclaimed film/TV
cameraman and cinematographer, in 2017 Paul 'Mungo' Mungeam stepped in front of
it to present a new cryptozoology-themed TV documentary show entitled Expedition Mungo. Each of its episodes
(filmed in 2016 and early 2017) saw him and his own film crew visit a different
location around the world allegedly inhabited by a mysterious creature
seemingly unknown to science. One of these episodes saw them in Liberia's Lofa
County, seeking the gbahali, and where they actually interviewed Sheppard on
screen.
Rainforest in Liberia's Lofa County (©) M Rödel et al./Wikipedia – CC BY 4.0 licence)
Mungo's
gbahali expedition focused its attention upon the Kahai River and its
tributaries, where this greatly-feared creature is known by the locals to exist
and where, therefore, they avoid as much as possible unless it is absolutely
essential to cross from one riverbank to another or to hunt for food there. One
villager named Momo informed Mungo that he and his brother had encountered a
ghahali on land once while they were hunting on the Kahai River, but once seen
it disappeared into the water.
Discounting
the possibility that it was merely a crocodile, Momo stated that its head was
lizard-like but with its eyes placed far back on it, a trait often exhibited by
aquatic animals, and its teeth were interlocking. Moreover, although it walked
on all fours like a crocodile, its body was raised up, held off the ground to a
greater degree than a crocodile's is. He also mentioned to Mungo that one such
creature had killed and devoured three men who had been attempting to cross the
Kahai on a raft at dusk.
Similarly,
another alleged gbahali eyewitness interviewed by Mungo, a man named Isaac from
Monena, a remote Liberian frontier village, recalled an oft-told claimed
killing of a man in a shallow river by a gbahali. The man had been attempting
to cross the river on foot to reach a party of fisherman friends on the far
bank. His friends told him not to cross, because a gbahali had been seen there
earlier that same day, but he ignored their advice and proceeded to wade
across. Before he could reach the other side, however, a gbahali surfaced,
seized the man, and dragged him beneath the water, never to be seen again.
As for
Isaac's own sighting, which had occurred not long before Mungo had arrived at
Monena in early 2017: just like Momo, Isaac had been fishing with his own
brother on the river nearby when he saw something swimming towards his brother:
He turned around and said:
"It looks like a crocodile". I said: "Hey, that is not a
crocodile, that is an animal bigger than a crocodile". We're talking about
the Gbahali...The mouth was in the form of a lizard.
Isaac
estimated the gbahali to have measured around 20 ft long, and insisted that it
was very different in appearance from a crocodile.
Also
interviewed by Mungo at Monena was fisherman Seiku, who divides his time
between this village and a camp on an even more remote stretch of the Kahai.
Seiku claimed to have seen a gbahali twice during his travails along this route
in September 2016, again not long before Mungo's arrival here.
Several
other villagers interviewed by Mungo at Monena also claimed to have seen a
gbahali, but as Sheppard had discovered earlier during his own investigations,
they did not consider it to be in any way magical or paranormal, just a normal,
ordinary creature like all of the other animal species inhabiting this
locality.
Sadly,
Mungo and his team did not have any sightings of their own, but if, as
fervently averred by Liberia's Lofa County hunters and fishermen, the gbahali
is indeed a real, flesh-and-blood beast, what might it be?
The
most conservative identity is the Nile crocodile (Liberia's other three
crocodile species are much too small and/or wary of human proximity). Although
officially confined to this country's coastal swamps, perhaps some stragglers
have penetrated further inland, reaching rivers, tributaries, and surrounding
terrain containing plenty of suitable prey, enabling them to thrive and
establish viable populations there, and possibly eventually attaining greater
sizes than their coastal ancestors, their increased weight readily buoyed by their
watery habitat.
Yet
the locals are adamant that the gbahali is no ordinary crocodile, or even a
crocodile at all, emphasizing its short-snouted, lizard-like head and its more
erect limbs as notable differentiating features. Also, its claimed behaviour of
killing its prey in the water by drowning it but then bringing it onto land to
consume it differs from typical crocodile feeding behaviour, in which the prey
is normally eaten in the water, the latter being utilized as a means of
softening the prey's carcase for easier consumption.
An alternative crocodilian option to consider is an unknown giant-sized species or morphological variety of West Africa's Osteolaemus
dwarf crocodile. This is certainly appealing, inasmuch as it would
combine the latter's shorter muzzle and more terrestrial lifestyle as
reported also for the gbahali with the gbahali's extra-large size.
Looking beyond crocodiles, Liberia
is home to some sizeable monitor lizards (varanids), including the West African
Nile monitor Varanus stellatus, up to
7.2 ft long, whose heads, more erect stance than crocodiles, and terrestrial
consumption of prey recall the gbahali. However, the latter's great size (even
allowing for exaggeration upon the part of its frightened eyewitnesses) and its
very distinctive armoured, tri-serrated dorsal surface do not.
Nile monitor with body raised on semi-erect legs
(© Charles J Sharp/Wikipedia – CC BY-SA 4.0 licence)
Now
for the Postosuchus possibility. On
the one hand, as noted earlier here, in terms of both shape and size a
reconstruction illustration of this creature was compared quite favourably with
the gbahali's alleged appearance by the villagers to whom Sheppard showed it.
Also, its fossils have been found in locations believed to have hosted back in
the time of Postosuchus an
environment similar to the present-day habitat in Liberia where the gbahali
reputedly exists, i.e. tropical, moist, and plant-plentiful, well-supplied with
rivers and other expanses of freshwater.
Conversely,
Postosuchus belongs to a
long-extinct, wholly prehistoric family of reptiles known only from what is now
North America, and existing during the late Triassic Period, i.e. approximately
201-237 million years ago – none of which bodes well for it being a plausible
identity for the gbahali.
True,
we cannot entirely rule out the prospect that the latter constitutes a
modern-day Old World descendant of Postosuchus
that has somehow entirely evaded scientific detection (like its presumed fossil
antecedents here), especially in such a heavily-forested remote region as
northern Liberia. Nevertheless, the further back in time that the original
creature existed, and the further away geographically-speaking that it existed
from where its postulated descendant does today, the less likely such an
example of prehistoric survival is, by definition.
In
addition, based upon its shorter forelegs, Postosuchus
is nowadays commonly deemed to have been at least partly, if not
exclusively, bipedal, whereas the gbahali is wholly quadrupedal. Also, Postosuchus is believed to have been
terrestrial, rather than aquatic or at least amphibious in lifestyle as the
gbahali is stated to be.
Postosuchus depicted in bipedal stance and compared in size with a human
(Dr Jeff Martz-NPS/Wikipedia, released into the public domain)
Another
putative prehistoric survivor that has been considered as a possible gbahali
candidate is some form of modern-day descendant of Kaprosuchus saharicus. This was a 20-ft-long semi-aquatic species
of mahajangasuchid crocodyliform that sported an armoured snout for slamming
its prey down, plus three pairs of sizeable tusks for tearing the latter's
flesh. These teeth have earned for it the nickname 'BoarCroc', due to their
superficial resemblance to the tusks of wild boars.
Unlike
Postosuchus, K. saharicus, as its name indicates, did live in Africa (its
fossilized remains have been excavated in what is today Niger), but
approximately 95 million years ago, during the Late Cretaceous. Consequently,
it is beset by much the same chronological issues as Postosuchus when under consideration as a plausible example of
prehistoric survival.
Reconstruction of possible appearance in life of Kaprosuchus (© Nobu Tamura/Wikipedia – CC BY 3.0 licence)
If
only there could be a known, historically-recent creature resembling and
behaving rather like the gbahali. In fact, there is – or was. The mekosuchines
constitute a taxonomic clade of crocodilians that included certain
representatives which persisted into the present-day geological epoch, the
Holocene (beginning less than 12,000 years ago), on various Pacific island
groups, including Fiji, Vanuatu, and New Caledonia.
Indeed,
one genus, Mekosuchus, survived on
those islands until at least as recently as 3,000 years ago, possibly even
longer (as late as 1720 BP, i.e. 300 AD, in the case of the youngest species, M. inexpectatus), before apparently
being exterminated when humans arrived there (although, tellingly, there is no
direct evidence for this, only speculation based upon the fates of other island
endemics once our own species reached their insular domains). Various other,
older mekosuchine genera, such as Quinkana,
as well as earlier Mekosuchus
representatives, formerly existed on mainland Australia.
Mekosuchus inexpectatus, showing neck and short snout (© Armin
Reindl/Wikipedia – CC BY-SA 4.0 licence)
M. inexpectatus in particular was
notable for its short snout, and like its other historically-recent Mekosuchus kin is thought to have
adopted a much more upright stance and mode of walking than any of today's
known crocodilians, all of which draws comparisons with the gbahali. So too
does the consensus that M. inexpectatus
probably inhabited tropical rivers and streams, just like West Africa's
present-day dwarf crocodiles, possibly coming onto land at night to feed.
In
stark contrast to the gbahali, however, mekosuchines were of only very modest
dimensions, generally no more than 6 ft in total length, sometimes even shorter
than that. Also, just as Postosuchus is
known only from the New World, mekosuchines are known only from Oceania; there
is none on record from Africa, or anywhere else in the world.
Even
so, the mekosuchines are relevant to the gbahali saga inasmuch as their
existence, albeit far-removed geographically from the latter cryptid, confirms
that at least some crocodilians of comparable appearance to it (excluding total
length) are indeed known from modern times, thus providing a notable precedent
– and that may not be all.
Convergent
evolution is a familiar phenomenon whereby animals in widely disparate
geographical localities and often of only distant taxonomic affinity
nevertheless transform through time into outwardly similar creatures due to
sharing the same ecological habitat and niche. So could it be that
ecologically-speaking, the taxonomically-distant gbahali has nonetheless
evolved a mekosuchine morphology by existing in a habitat comparable to that of
the latter crocodilians, but has attained a much greater size due to its
habitat's remote location coupled with the fear that it generates among human
hunters, who generally prefer to avoid it rather than confront it? As suggested earlier here, a giant-sized Osteolaemus comes to mind.
In
short (unlike the gbahali itself, which is allegedly anything but short!),
could Liberia's mystery reptile be a totally novel, as well as a currently
undescribed, species of African crocodilian?
Alternatively,
turning full circle through the succession of identities considered here, might
this cryptid simply be an unusually large form of Nile crocodiles after all?
The reason that I've returned to this option is that I am well aware that there
is a common tendency among local non-scientific people who intimately share
their lives alongside large, potentially dangerous creatures to give a
completely separate name to exceptionally large specimens of such a species
from the name that they give to normal-sized specimens of that same species,
treating the outliers as a fundamentally different animal type from their
typically-sized brethren.
So
might it simply be that reports of gbahalis are nothing more than reports of
exceptionally large Nile crocodiles that have been given this separate local
name?
The
problem with such a proposed resolution to the gbahali mystery, however, is that
we can only accept this by conveniently ignoring the other morphological, and
behavioural, differences from normal Nile crocodiles that the locals ascribe to
the gbahali – which in my opinion would be very unwise.
The Nile crocodile's very long snout, differing
markedly from the gbahali's supposed short snout according to eyewitness
testimony (© Reinhold Möller/Wikipedia – CC BY-SA 4.0 licence) History
has shown time and again how, by taking heed of local, native testimony,
extraordinary animals hitherto dismissed by Western zoologists as mere folklore
have been formally discovered and revealed to be remarkable species entirely
new to science.
So,
might the gbahali one day prove to be another one? In view of the giant forest
hog, pygmy hippo, Jentink's duiker, and the Liberian mongoose, I'd have to
think more than twice before betting against such a prospect.
For full details concerning the discoveries
of the four Liberian mammals noted above, be sure to check out my three books
on new and rediscovered animals:
Posts
