It was 80 years ago this year when the pamphlet
pictured above in this present ShukerNature blog post was published. A humble,
unassuming little offering entitled The Home of the Loch Ness Monster,
just 18 pages long, containing only a single illustration, and privately
published by its author, a retired British army man named Lieutenant-Colonel
William Horsburgh Lane who lived in a house on the shores of Loch Ness, it
documented Lane's considered belief that the Loch Ness monster (LNM) may be a
giant form of salamander. This particular zoological identity would be revisited
and revitalised more than four decades later by Chicago University biochemist
and veteran Nessie researcher Prof. Roy P. Mackal in his own much more
detailed, highly-acclaimed study, The Monsters of Loch Ness (1976),
which remains a standard work on the subject.
Conversely, Lane's very modest contribution to the
LNM literature is all but forgotten today and exceedingly rare, making it much
sought-after by Nessie aficionados – but not only because if its scarcity. What
gives his pamphlet a unique, unassailable, and truly historic place within the
cryptozoological canon, and the reason why I am celebrating today its
publication in that long-ago year of 1934, is that it was the very first entire,
stand-alone work (i.e. book, pamphlet, magazine, as opposed to merely an
article in a magazine or a report in a newspaper) devoted exclusively to the
LNM.
This, therefore, is where it all began – the
trickle that became a stream that became a river that became a veritable ocean
of Nessie-themed books published in the 80 years that have followed in the wake
of Lane's pamphlet – and what a number there have been, as I am about to
reveal.
I recently disclosed on Facebook that I am
currently completing a compendium volume that brings together pretty well
everything that I have ever written on the subject of the LNM – drawn from my
books, articles, and ShukerNature blog posts, expanded and updated as required,
and accompanied by a purposefully eclectic selection of illustrations, many of
which have never been published before, including a number specially prepared for
it by some very talented artist friends of mine.
Entitled Here's Nessie! A Monstrous
Compendium From Loch Ness, it will also include what I am hoping will be
the most comprehensive bibliography of Nessie-themed non-fiction books ever
compiled. As with all such lists, however, no matter how comprehensive it may
seem to be to its compiler, there will always be some entries that he will have
overlooked, and especially so in relation to foreign–language (non-English)
books.
Consequently, in the hope of plugging as many
potential gaps in this bibliography as possible, I am presenting below the
version that I have compiled so far, and would very greatly welcome any
suggested additions from readers (and also any info regarding the few missing
places of publication in the list). Please note, however, that I am not looking
for books that only contain a single chapter or two on Nessie – all books included
in this bibliography must be ones that are devoted entirely to the LNM (or to
any other Scottish loch monsters), and they must also be works of non-fiction,
not novels or other works of fiction. Thanks very much in advance for any
assistance that you may be able to offer me, and enjoy the list!
My sincere thanks to Errol Fuller for originally
bringing Lieut.-Col.
Lane's
pamphlet to my attention, and for very kindly supplying me with the image of
its front cover that opens this ShukerNature blog post.
A
BIBLIOGRAPHY OF NESSIE-THEMED NON-FICTION BOOKS
ANON., They
Saw Nessie (Or Thought They Did!): Eye-Witness Sightings of the Monster Over
the Years (Northern Books, from Famedram: Gartocharn, 1984).
ABELS, Harriette & SCHROEDER, Howard, The Loch Ness Monster (Crestwood House: New York, 1987).
AKINS, William, The Loch Ness Monster (Signet: New York, 1977).
AKINS, William, The Loch Ness Monster (Signet: New York, 1977).
ARMSTRONG,
Edward, Sticking My Neck Out (Privately published: [no place of
publication details], 1983).
BAUER, Henry H.,
The Enigma of Loch Ness: Making Sense of a Mystery (University of
Illinois Press: Urbana, 1986).
BAUMANN, Elwood
D., The Loch Ness Monster (Franklin Watts: New York, 1972).
BAXTER, Colin, The
Loch Ness Monster (Colin Baxter Photography: Grantown on Spey, 2012).
BENDICK, Jeanne, The Mystery of the Loch Ness Monster (McGraw-Hill: London, 1976).
BENDICK, Jeanne, The Mystery of the Loch Ness Monster (McGraw-Hill: London, 1976).
BERTON, Jean, Les
Monstres du Loch Ness et d'Ailleurs (France-Empire: Paris, 1977).
BINNS, Ronald, The
Loch Ness Mystery Solved (Open Books: Shepton Mallet, 1983).
BORDER,
Rosemary, Loch Ness Monster (Macdonald Phoebus: London, 1979).
BRASSEY,
Richard, Nessie the Loch Ness Monster (Orion: London, 2010).
BURTON, Maurice,
The Elusive Monster: An Analysis of the Evidence From Loch Ness (Rupert
Hart-Davis: London, 1961).
BYRNE, Gerald, Gestalt
Forms of Loch Ness (JRP Ringler: Zurich, 2011).
CAMPBELL,
Elizabeth M. & SOLOMON, David, The Search For Morag (Tom Stacey:
London, 1972).
CAMPBELL,
Steuart, The Loch Ness Monster: The Evidence (Aquarian: Wellingborough,
1986; rev. edit., Aberdeen University Press: London, 1991).
CARNEY, James, Loch
Ness Monster (Colin Baxter Photography: Grantown on Spey, 2009).
CARRUTH, J.A., Loch
Ness and Its Monster (Abbey Press: Fort Augustus, 1945).
CASSIE, R.L., The
Monsters of Achanalt (2 vols) (D. Wyllie & Sons: Aberdeen, 1935-36).
COOK, D. &
COOK, Y., The Great Monster Hunt: The Story of the Loch Ness Investigation
(Grosset & Dunlap: New York, 1969).
CORNELL, James, The
Monster of Loch Ness (Scholastic Book Services: New York, 1977).
DINSDALE, Angus,
The Man Who Filmed Nessie (Hancock House: New York, 2013).
DINSDALE, Tim, Loch
Ness Monster (Routledge & Kegan Paul: London, 1961; 4th edit., 1982).
DINSDALE, Tim, The
Story of the Loch Ness Monster (Allan Wingate: London, 1973).
DINSDALE, Tim, Project
Water Horse: The True Story of the Monster Quest at Loch Ness (Routledge
& Kegan Paul: London, 1975).
FLITCROFT, Jean,
The Loch Ness Monster [The Cryptid Files #1] (Darby Creek Publishing:
Minneapolis, 2014).
GANTES, Rémy, Le
Mystère du Loch Ness (Etudes Vivantes: Paris, 1979).
GIBSON, John A.
& HEPPELL, David (Eds), Proceedings of the Symposium on the Loch Ness
Monster: "The Search For Nessie in the 1980s" (Scottish Natural
History Library: Foremount House, 1988).
GOULD, Rupert
T., The Loch Ness Monster and Others (Geoffrey Bles: London, 1934).
GRIMSHAW, Roger
& LESTER, Paul, The Meaning of the Loch Ness Monster (Birmingham
University: Birmingham, 1976).
HAMILTON, W.D.
& HUGHES, J., The Mysterious Monster of Loch Ness (Fort Augustus
Abbey Press: Fort Augustus, 1934).
HANSEN, Kim M., Mysteriet
om Nessie: Søslangen i Loch Ness (Gyldendal: Copenhagen, 1988).
HARMSWORTH,
Tony, The Mysterious Monsters of Loch Ness (Precision Press: 1980).
HARMSWORTH,
Tony, Loch Ness: The Monster (Peter Gray Ltd: Tillicoultry, 1985).
HARMSWORTH,
Tony, Loch Ness, Nessie & Me: The Truth Revealed [vt Nessie
Understood] (Harmsworth.net: Drumnadrochit, 2010).
HARRISON, Paul, The
Encyclopedia of the Loch Ness Monster (Robert Hale: London, 1999).
HASTAIN, Ronald
& WITCHELL, Nicholas, Loch Ness and the Monster: A Handbook For Tourists
(J. Arthur Dixon: Inverness, 1971).
HAUF, Monika, Nessie
– Das Ungeheur von Loch Ness (Bohmeier Verlag: Leipzig, 2003).
HILE, Lori, The
Loch Ness Monster (Capstone Global Library: Oxford, 2013).
HOLIDAY, F.W., The
Great Orm of Loch Ness: A Practical Inquiry Into the Nature and Habits of
Water-Monsters (Faber & Faber: London, 1968).
JAMES, David, Loch
Ness Investigation (Loch Ness Phenomena Investigation Bureau: London,
1968).
KALLEN, Stuart
A., The Loch Ness Monster (Referencepoint Press: San Diego, 2008).
KIRKPATRICK,
Betty, Nessie: The Legend of the Loch Ness Monster (Crombie Jardine
Publishing: Cheam, 2005).
KLEIN, Martin, et
al., Underwater Search at Loch Ness [Monograph No. 1] (Academy of
Applied Science: Belmont, 1972).
LANE,
W[illiam].H., The Home of the Loch Ness Monster (Moray Press:
Edinburgh, 1934).
MacRAE, Jim, Loch
Ness Monster Handbook (John G. Eccles: Inverness, 1974).
MACKAL, Roy P., The
Monsters of Loch Ness (Macdonald and Janes: London, 1976).
MARTIN, David
& BOYD, Alistair, Nessie: The Surgeon's Photograph Exposed (Martin
and Boyd: East Burnet, 1999).
MEREDITH, Dennis
L., The Search at Loch Ness: The Expedition of the New York Times and the
Academy of Applied Science (Quadrangle: New York, 1977).
MILLER, Connie
C., El Monstruo del Lago Ness: El Misterio Sin Resolver / The Loch
Ness Monster: The Unsolved Mystery (Blazers Bilingual: North Mankato,
2009).
MUNRO, Donald
J., Loch Ness Mystery (Privately published: [no place of publication
details], 1937).
OUDEMANS, A.C., The
Loch Ness Animal (Leyden: London, 1934).
OWEN, William, Loch
Ness Revealing Its Monsters (Jarrold: Norwich, 1976).
OWEN, William, The
Loch Ness Monster [vt Scotland's Loch Ness Monster] (Jarrold:
Norwich, 1986).
PARKS, Peggy J.,
The Loch Ness Monster (KidHaven: Farmington Hills, 2006).
PERERA, Victor, The
Loch Ness Monster Watchers (Capra Press: Santa Barbara, 1974).
PICKNETT, Lynn, The
Loch Ness Monster (Pitkin Pictorials: Andover, 1993).
RINES, Robert
H., et al., Underwater Search At Loch Ness (Academy of Applied
Science: New York, 1972).
RUSSELL, Jessie
& COHN, Ronald (Eds), Loch Ness Monster in Popular Culture [a hard-copy compilation of
Wikipedia articles] (Bookvika Publishing: Moscow, 2012).
RUSSELL, Jessie & COHN, Ronald (Eds), Loch Ness Monster [a hard-copy compilation of Wikipedia articles] (Bookvika Publishing: Moscow, 2012).
RUSSELL, Jessie & COHN, Ronald (Eds), Loch Ness Monster [a hard-copy compilation of Wikipedia articles] (Bookvika Publishing: Moscow, 2012).
SAN SOUCI, Robert D. (Ed.), The Loch Ness Monster: Opposing Viewpoints (Greenhaven Press: San Diego, 1989).
SCHACH, David, The Loch Ness Monster (Torque Books: Minneapolis, 2010).
SCHACH, David, The Loch Ness Monster (Torque Books: Minneapolis, 2010).
SEARLE, Frank, Nessie:
Seven Years in Search of the Monster (Coronet: London, 1976).
SEARLE, Frank, The
Story of Loch Ness (John Eccles: Inverness, 1977).
SEARLE, Frank, Around
Loch Ness: A Handbook For Nessie Hunters (John Eccles: Inverness, 1977).
SENSICAL,
Benjamin, Loch Ness: An Explanation (Privately published: [no place of
publication details], 1982).
SHINE, Adrian, Loch
Ness? (Loch Ness Project: Drumnadrochit, 2006).
SHUKER, Karl
P.N., Here's Nessie! A Monstrous Compendium From Loch Ness (CFZ Press:
Bideford, 2016).
SIEVERT, Terri, The
Unsolved Mystery of the Loch Ness Monster (First Fact Books: North Mankato,
2013).
SNYDER, Gerald
S., Is There a Loch Ness Monster? The Search For a Legend (Julian
Messner: New York, 1977).
THORNE, Ian, The Loch Ness Monster (Crestwood House: New York, 1978).
TROUPE, Thomas K., The Legend of the Loch Ness Monster (Picture Window Books: North Mankato, 2011).
TROUPE, Thomas K., The Legend of the Loch Ness Monster (Picture Window Books: North Mankato, 2011).
VIBE, Palle, Gaden
I Loch Ness (Rhodos: Copenhagen, 1970).
WALLACE, Holly, The
Mystery of the Loch Ness Monster (Capstone Global Library: Oxford, 2006).
WATSON, Roland, The
Water Horses of Loch Ness (CreateSpace: London, 2011).
WELSH, Lily
(Ed.), Monsters and Myths: Loch Ness and the Monster [a hard-copy
compilation of Wikipedia articles] (Webster's Digital Services: 2010).
WHYTE, Constance,
The Loch Ness Monster (Headley Brothers: London, 1951).
WHYTE,
Constance, More Than a Legend: The Story of the Loch Ness Monster
(Hamish Hamilton: London, 1957; rev. 1961).
WITCHELL,
Nicholas, The Loch Ness Story (Terence Dalton: Lavenham, 1974; 3rd edit.,
Corgi Books: London, 1989).
WITCHELL,
Nicholas, Loch Ness and the Monster (J. Arthur Dixon: Newport, 1975).
This Loch Ness monster bibliography is excerpted
from my forthcoming book, Here's Nessie! A
Monstrous Compendium from Loch Ness, which will be published in 2016 by CFZ Press.
The parallel list maintained at Glasgow Boy's Loch Ness Monster blog has slightly different rules than yours. His: no fiction, no juveniles, no foreign language. Yours: no fiction, no partials, and I'm not sure where you stand on juveniles. There are a few items from his list that might qualify adding to yours, by Warren Smith, Barrie Robertson, Alex Harvey, Joseph W. Zarzynski, and J.F. Derry, possibly others. He mentions in another post a second compendium of Wikipedia articles by Russell & Cohn, "Loch Ness Monster in Popular Culture." One of his commenters at the main list mentions nine additional titles, one of which you've already captured (William Owen's "Loch Ness Revealing Its Monsters"). Of the other eight, several may be fiction or juvenile, but several appear to be straight adult non-fiction, and probably all eight should be investigated to make sure.
ReplyDeletehttp://lochnessmystery.blogspot.co.uk/2012/03/books-on-loch-ness-monster_13.html
http://lochnessmystery.blogspot.co.uk/2012/11/nessie-books-plesiosaurs-plagiarism-and.html
http://lochnessmystery.blogspot.co.uk/2013/06/some-old-and-new-nessie-books.html
Thanks for the info, Patrick - I'll check out Glasgow Boy's bibliography, but yes, I do include juvenile titles in my list, as long as they are clearly non-fiction, and I am particularly interested in adding as many foreign-language titles as possible. Because all books must concentrate entirely on Nessie (and/or other Scottish Loch monsters, e.g. Morag of Loch Morar), I have reluctantly had to omit certain classic works, such as Tim Dinsdale's The Leviathans and its updated American edition retitled Monster Hunt, as well as Peter Costello's In Search of Lake Monsters. I'll add to my bibliography the relevant ones from your above comment, so thanks again! All the best, Karl
DeleteI've now checked out Glasgow Boy's bibliography, but the works in it by Smith, Derry, Robertson, and Zarzynski all come under my categorisation of partials, and the Harvey item, though entertainingly quirky, as a booklet accompanying a CD is not really a stand-alone item. But I'll now go through the nine titles mentioned by one of his commentators, and see if they qualify. Thanks again for the suggestions.
DeleteIncidentally, I definitely want to mention that Glasgow Boy's Nessie blog is a wonderful, exceptionally well-researched and written fund of LNM information, which I definitely recommend to anyone interested in this subject.
DeleteI did a little work on that list of nine. You actually already have three on your list: William Owen's "Loch Ness Revealing Its Monsters," Owen's "Scotland's Loch Ness Monster" (as a variant title for "The Loch Ness Monster"), and Rosemary Border's "Loch Ness Monster." That leaves six, of which one, the Furneauxes' "The Loch Ness Monster and Other Mysteries," is a partial (as indicated by its title), and another, John Bateman's "Loch Ness Conspiracy," appears to be a novel. Down to four! Three are apparently relevant juvenile titles - Harriette Sheffer Abels's "The Loch Ness Monster," Jeanne Bendick's "The Mystery of the Loch Ness Monster," and Ian Thorne's "The Loch Ness Monster." The fourth, Robert D. San Souci's "The Loch Ness Monster: Opposing Viewpoints," appears to be adult non-fiction (in a "casebook" series).
ReplyDeleteLooking a little more closely at a few items already on your list: Jean Flitcroft's "The Loch Ness Monster" might be eliminated, as it appears to be juvenile fiction. I believe that the Martin Klein et al. and Robert Rines et al. "Underwater Search at Loch Ness," listed separately, are the same book.
Also, the Colin Baxter and John Carney titles on your list might be the same book in different editions.
ReplyDeleteEven Mackal abandoned the giant salamander theory in later years. But Gould favored Lane's theory, and Sanderson seemed intrigued by it. It has perhaps regained some momentum in recent years.
ReplyDelete