My very own giant dragonfly, chanced upon in a charity shop
recently and now residing in my study (© Dr Karl Shuker)
This ShukerNature blog article of mine
documents an entomological enigma of the cryptozoological kind that has long
fascinated, me but which I've never previously blogged about. Namely, the extraordinary
possibility that extra-large dragonflies, veritable giants in some cases, exist
unrecognised by science in our modern-day world. Consequently, I have gathered
here an exclusive selection of such reports for your perusal. First of all,
however, I'd like to set the scene for them by presenting a couple of comparable
examples plucked from traditional folklore and medieval fancy.
GIANT
DRAGONFLIES IN FOLKLORE
On 16 August 2015, I documented here on
ShukerNature (and subsequently redocumented in expanded form within the first
of my ShukerNature compendium books, ShukerNature Book 1: Antlered Elephants, Locust
Dragons, and Other Cryptic Blog Beasts, 2019), a fascinating but thoroughly baffling
centuries-old engraving illustrating a mysterious beast so bizarre in
appearance that I dubbed it the locust dragon (click here
to view my original blog article concerning it).
The original source of this specific
engraving was a series of prints produced in Antwerp, Belgium, by Flemish
engraver Nicolaes de Bruyn (1571-1656) in 1594 that depicted various flying
creatures.
Although he is best known for his many
biblically-themed engravings and his large engraved landscapes reproducing
designs and paintings by other artists, de Bruyn produced approximately 400
works in total, including a number that featured animals.
Nicolaes de Bruyn's
mystifying engraving from 1594, depicting a wide range of readily-identifiable
insects, plus what can only be described as a truly bizarre 'locust dragon'
(public domain)
The series containing the locust dragon was
entitled Volatilium Varii Generis Effigies ('Pictures of Flying Creatures
of Varied Kinds'), and was first published by Ahasuerus van Londerseel
(1572-1635) of Amsterdam.
It was subsequently reissued (with van
Londerseel's name neatly trimmed off!) by Carel Allard in 1663 (or shortly
after – there are conflicting accounts concerning this detail).
My investigation of what the locust dragon
might conceivably have been attracted a number of replies from readers, posted
beneath my blog article, including one whose subject was entirely new to me and
very intriguing.
Posted on 30 August 2015 by a reader with
the memorable Google username Dracula van Helsing, it mentioned that de Bruyn's
grotesque locust dragon reminded him of a legend from Cantabria, a region in
northern Spain, concerning certain horse-like demonic dragonflies known as
Caballucos (aka Caballitos) del Diablu ('little horses of the devil', despite
being said to be at least as big as real horses!).
Giant model of a southern damselfly Coenagrion mercuriale, a very eyecatching species of slender-bodied
dragonfly native to Britain and several countries across mainland Europe (© Dr
Karl Shuker)
Here is Wikipedia's then-current entry on
these very intriguing yet little-known mythical beasts, which has since been
reworded somewhat and expanded (see also below), but was originally derived
from Manuel Llano
Merino's book Mitos y Leyendas de Cantabria, published in 2001:
On St John's Eve (June 23), when the people
make bonfires to purify their souls, giant dragonflies appear amongst the
ashes. These dragonflies - the Caballucos - are the souls of sinners, and they
come to release their fury over a year's worth of sins with fire and terrifying
screams.
The Caballucos del Diablu appear in a
variety of colors, each one being the soul of a different sinner. The red horse
was a man who lent money to farmers and then used dirty tricks to steal their
properties; the white one a miller who stole many thousands of dollars from his
master; the black one a hermit who played tricks on people; the yellow one a
corrupt judge; the blue one an innkeeper; and the orange one a child who abused
his parents.
Worryingly
close to a giant damselfly! (© Dr Karl Shuker)
And here is this entry's present version, i.e. as of
today, 28 November 2023:
On St John's Eve (June 23)
at night; when the people make bonfires to purify their souls, horses
(Percheron purebred) with damselfly wings [damselflies are slender-bodied
dragonfly species], black manes and foaming mouths appear amongst the ashes.
These stallions – the Caballucos – are the souls of sinners, damned to roam
Cantabria for eternity, come to release their fury over a year's worth of sins,
creating a rumbling explosion with fire accompanied by terrifying screams.
The Caballucos del Diablu
appear in a variety of colors, each one being the soul of a different sinner,
as legends highlight. The red horse was a man who lent money to farmers and
then used dirty tricks to steal their properties; the white one a miller who
stole many thousands of dollars from his master; the black one a hermit who
played tricks on people; the yellow one a corrupt judge; the blue one an
innkeeper; and the orange one a child who abused his parents;[1] the green one a lord who possessed
many lands and dishonoured plenty of young women. It is said that the Devil
himself roams the streets riding the red fire-breathing steed, the sturdiest
and most powerful who leads the raid, while other demons ride the rest. The
force in their stomping is such that their horseshoes leave prints on rocks, as
if they were freshly ploughed soil. They have gleaming eyes, and blow a strong
wind with their nostrils to try impeding lovers from giving corsages to the
girls. The huffs, as cold as winter, are strong enough to make leaves fall from
trees and bushes. The horses’s food are shamrocks, with they eat tastefully,
probably to prevent the seekers who come out at night from finding any. The
Caballucos pounce on everyone they come across, the only things that repels
them is a bunch of vervain that the person can carry along; the plant has to be
collected the day before though, or should be placed next to St John’s fire, to
which they won’t come near. The locals note that sometimes, after becoming worn
out by the search, the Caballucos stop to rest and their saliva drips on the
ground, and turns into gold ingots. Whoever takes them will be made extremely
wealthy, but will descent straight to hell after death.
Obverse
side of a stele
(carved upright stone) from San Vicente de Toranzo (Cantabria), depicting a
ridden Cabulluco del Diablu, and displayed at the Museum of Prehistory and
Archaeology of Cantabria, Spain (© Valdavia/Wikipedia – CC BY-SA 3.0 licence)
Yet although giant dragonflies of equine appearance would
undoubtedly be eyecatching in their own right if such creatures ever existed in
reality as opposed to mere mythology, they would not bear any tangible
resemblance to the enigmatic entity upon which my locust dragon investigations
have been focused.
Interestingly, what has been described by some writers as
a four-legged, horse-headed dragonfly is also portrayed in the Luttrell
Psalter, an English illuminated manuscript dating from c.1325-1340.
However, as can readily be perceived here, the
illustration of this incongruous insect bears no resemblance to those of the
locust dragon.
A four-legged, horse-headed dragonfly
depicted in the Luttrell Psalter (public domain)
But
that is still not all as far as controversial giant dragonflies or
dragonfly-like mystery beasts of the decidedly daunting kind are concerned.
GIANT DRAGONFLIES IN FACT?
One
of the fantastical lands visited by physician Dr Lemuel Gulliver in Jonathan
Swift's famous satirical fantasy novel Gulliver's
Travels (1726) is Brobdingnag, a remote, hitherto-unexplored peninsula of
the western USA, whose human inhabitants and wildlife are all of gigantic
proportions.
Accordingly,
in real life the adjective 'Brobdingnagian' is often applied to anything of
extraordinarily large size – and could therefore be definitely applied in
relation to certain reports in the cryptozoology archives of supposedly real
but unequivocally oversized dragonflies.
A painting of
Gulliver being inspected by one of the giants of Brobdingnag – note the
enormous wasp in the foreground! (public domain)
One of
these was posted on Lon Strickler's Phantoms and Monsters website, and reads as follows:
Me and my younger brother
saw a huge dragonfly spanning well over a foot and half long in Bolton, England
in 2002. It must have been over an inch in diameter as well at the centre. I
would have questioned myself but as it was witnessed by someone else too. I’m
pretty sure it wasn’t just me seeing things. Sometimes I think was it an RC [radio/remote-controlled]
helicopter? But no way could it move with such swiftness, agility and silence
especially with 2002 technology. I went to the Manchester museum and checked
with the insect experts and they said it sounds like you’ve seen something from
the prehistoric and that no species of dragonfly that exist today are that
large. It’s not a giant bird but has anyone ever seen these massive
dragonflies? I would love some confirmation some more witnesses across the
world.
Two
years after this sighting, two comparable ones were posted online in the forum
of the Charles Fort Institute's website on the very same day, 25 July 2004. One
of these was posted by someone I know personally, a well-respected naturalist
named Oll Lewis. Here is his typically matter-of-fact account of his encounter,
which took place in the Vale of Glamorgan, Wales:
I have seen a large
dragonfly before, I live near a large country park with 2 huge lakes and
extensive reed beds so if there were an ideal place for dragonfly and damselfly
spotting, that's it. The largest dragonfly I observed was in Cosmeston Lakes
Country Park [and] had a wingspan of at least 1/2 a meter [50 cm] skimming over
the surface of the lake about 3 metres from the bank. It was brownish yellow in
colour and apart from its size quite unremarkable.
I
subsequently learned from Oll that he had reported his sighting to a
university-based entomology professor, who blithely discounted it. The
longest-bodied dragonfly native to the UK is the golden-ringed dragonfly Cordulegaster boltonii, whose slender
elongate body can reach almost 8.5 cm long in adult females with fully-formed
ovipositors, and whose wingspan can be as much as 10 cm, The largest UK
dragonfly species in terms of wingspan is the emperor dragonfly Anax imperator, whose body averages
around 8 cm long but its wingspan is up to 10.5 cm. However, these species'
impressive dimensions still fall far short of those for the two mystery British
specimens described above.
The
second Charles Fort Institute forum report was posted by a contributor with the
username laphip. Here it is:
When I was around nine
years old me and my two sisters watched a dragonfly with a body about half a
metre long circle around our backyard just above the height of our bungalow (in
Edmonton, Alberta, Canada). When we told our mom about it, she just said it
must've been a toy plane shaped like a dragonfly. It looked quite naturally an
insect to me, and it made no sound. Would a dragonfly of that size make or not
make noise in flight? Can toy remote controlled planes be soundless?
Due to
their rapid aerial movements and continual hawking, the size of these insects
is notoriously difficult to gauge accurately, especially by eyewitnesses not
familiar with them. So overestimation of size would not be difficult. Having
said that, the above-noted mentions of remote/radio-controlled aircraft may
well be relevant, especially in light of an unexpected but fascinating
discovery that I made recently, and which I'll reveal later here.
Golden ringed dragonfly Cordulegaster boltonii, male (© Charles
J Sharp/Wikipedi – CC BY-SA 4.0 licence)
Another
report, forwarded to me in 2001 by Strange Magazine's founding editor,
the late Mark Chorvinsky, consists of a report e-mailed to him by correspondent
Victor Engel. It reads as follows:
You may be interested in an expedition I plan on this summer. In
May/June 1974 while driving through Mexico, I saw the largest dragonfly I've
ever seen. At the time I estimated its wingspan at 14 inches. Since that time,
I've not seriously searched for it again, but I have done some research. I've
contacted dragonfly experts and other insect experts. The general consensus in
the scientific community is that while there used to be dragonflies of that
size, and, in fact, even larger, they don't, and cannot exist today. The reason
cited for believing they cannot exist today is that the oxygen content of the
atmosphere is too low to support the high metabolism required for the dragonfly
to catch its prey. Then I got in touch with Dr Gilbert, of the University of
Texas at Austin, who is doing research with imported fire ants and their
parasitic phorid flies. He gave me two well thought-out lists. One was a list
of all the reasons why such a dragonfly cannot exist. The other was a list of
reasons why such an insect could possibly exist. Anyway, I'm so convinced at
what I saw in the 70s that now I'm making a special trip just to find one
again.
As
Engel correctly mentions, back in ancient prehistoric times there were dragonflies
– or, to be precise, dragonfly-resembling insects – that were even bigger than
the size estimate offered by him for his Mexican mystery specimen. These
veritable giants are known as griffinflies, in homage to those legendary winged
monsters the griffins, Originally housed together with the true dragonflies and
damselflies within the taxonomic order Odonata, griffinflies are nowadays
housed in a separate, extinct order, Meganisoptera.
Griffinfly in prehistoric
scene, vintage illustration (public domain)
Indeed,
fossil remains of Meganeura monyi, a dragonfly that lived approximately
300 million years ago during the late Carboniferous Era in what is today
France, indicate that it sported a spectacular wingspan of up to 29.5 in.
Moreover,
Meganeuropsis permiana, living during
the early Permian Era, sported a comparable wingspan, thereby making these the
largest insect species, past or present, currently known to science.
Blue-winged helicopter damselfly Megaloprepus caeruleatus (© Katja Schulz/Wikipedia
– CC BY 2.0 licence)
Today,
conversely, the largest Odonata member is the blue-winged helicopter Megaloprepus
caeruleatus, a damselfly native to Central and South America, whose wingspan
measures up to 7.52 in, and whose body length is up to 4.72 in. Hence Engel's
specimen, if accurately estimated, would have a wingspan twice this.
In a
JournalnewsOnline article of 15 February 2022, veteran mystery beast
investigator Brent Swancer recalled being told by a supposed giant dragonfly
eyewitness that he and a friend had been hiking together through Florida's
famous Everglades National Park on a clear day when they saw what seemed at
first to be a bird, but then they saw that it had four beating wings, not two, and
that its metallic green body was very elongate, measuring over 1 ft long.
Moreover, as they watched, the creature came close enough for them to discern
the multi-faceted form of its eyes, as characteristically exhibited by the
compound eyes of adult insects, hovering in front of them for a moment before
it swooped off again, its flight entirely silent throughout.
It is
well known that the tracheal-based respiratory system of insects, whose
internal network of minute cell-penetrating, air-transporting tubes is only
capable of transporting oxygen over tiny distances, precludes these creatures
from attaining the gargantuan sizes beloved of sci-fi movie makers, and even from
those attained by the long-demised griffinflies, as the oxygen content of the
atmosphere that existed way back in their time was much greater than it is
today.
Bearing
this in mind, therefore, what on earth – or anywhere else, for that matter! –
can we say about the absolutely ginormous dragonfly lookalikes that a reader
with the username PoeticsOfBigfoot posting to the cryptozoology website
Cryptomundo on 28 June 2013 claimed to have observed over a lengthy period one
evening in, fittingly, Texas?
Giant insects are more common in the Southwest than people
realize. I saw huge dragonfly-like insects around sundown near Terlingua TX
once. I estimate they were eight feet long or so, with about the same wingspan.
They had some sort of long whip-like appendage at their posterior end, a little
longer than their bodies, that arced upward. I saw three of them over a
two-hour time span.
Confronted by
a monster dragonfly sculpture of truly monstrous proportions in Wroclaw, Poland
(© Piotr
Przybyszewski/Wikipedia – CC BY 3.0 licence)
Male
dragonflies do possess a pair of claspers at the tip of their most posterior
abdominal segment, and females bear a single circus there, but these are
nowhere near as long as the insects' bodies. So too did griffinflies, but with
the same proviso. Moreover, for the respiratory reasons mentioned above, an
8-ft-long insect living today, most especially one as metabolically active as a
fast-flying dragonfly, would be a physiological impossibility.
And
even if it wasn't, such a spectacular, readily visible entity native to North
America would assuredly have been discovered, described, and fully documented
by science long ago. So although dragonflies are predatory, I wouldn't worry
unduly about being dive-bombed any time soon by the terrorflies of Terlingua!
Unless,
of course, this titanic trio had winged their way to Texas from Brobdingnag's
secluded peninsula??? Gulliver's remarkable travels and his numerous
hair-raising experiences during them had so transformed his personality that
after he finally returned safely home, he became a recluse. After encountering
monsters like these, can you blame him??
Fictional giant
dragonfly with long whip-like posterior process like the three 8-ft-long Texas
specimens (public domain)
Seriously,
however, I have recently learned to my surprise but delight that giant
radio-controlled dragonfly models not only exist but be readily purchased on
certain websites – so might these fascinating fliers explain such sightings, including
laphip's noted earlier here, especially if they were spied in dim light
conditions? Then again, eyewitnesses of such creatures have often claimed that
their flight was totally silent, thus suggesting that they weren't remote-controlled
aircraft or drones after all.
In short, unless we dismiss all such
reports as involving hoaxes, misidentifications of non-insect aerial creatures,
or exaggerated size estimates of bona fide dragonflies, the mystery of these
giant flying insects remains very much up in the air – as indeed do they!
For
my expanded coverage of the locust dragon, be sure to check out ShukerNature
Book 1, whose front cover sports a gorgeous
full-colour painting by longstanding friend and superb artist Anthony Walls, in
which he portrays me with said locust dragon perching contentedly on my
shoulder: